Serial Killer Database Wiki

Welcome to the Serial Killer Database. Check out our Youtube, and Reddit. And please look through the guidelines, page structure, Help and Policy pages, as well as the Manual of Style before you start contributing.

READ MORE

Serial Killer Database Wiki
Serial Killer Database Wiki
SKb
Similar M.O.s
This offender have a M.O. similar to that of Dean Corll and Javed Iqbal.
More citations needed
This article needs additional citations for verification.
Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Further details may exist on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
Find sources: "John Wayne Gacy"news · books · scholar · JSTOR

A clown can get away with murder.

Biography[]

This article lacks properly organized sections.
The content is currently presented in a way that lacks sufficient sectioning, making it difficult to read and navigate. Please help improve the structure by adding appropriate sections and headings. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Further details may exist on the talk page. (Augut 8, 2024)
Find sources: "John Gacy"news · books · scholar · JSTOR

Born in Chicago, Illinois, in 1942 to a Polish father and a Danish-Scottish mother, John was the second child of three, but the only boy. All of the Gacy children attended parochial school and Catholic church community. John was well liked by his teachers, held various part-time jobs, and was an active member of the Boy Scouts. Although his relationship with his father was strained because John could never gain his approval, along with the father being abusive, and some serious medical problems (a clot in the brain undiscovered from age eleven to sixteen, at seventeen unspecific heart troubles) his childhood was relatively normal.[2]

After an unhappy experience in Las Vegas, early in the peace and love generation of the 1960s he enrolled in college in Chicago and gained a degree in business. During this time he excelled at the art of selling. After promotions and accolades at his new job, Gacy settled down, got married, ending up managing a Kentucky Fried Chicken for his father in law.  In 1968, Gacy was convicted of molesting a minor working for him at Kentucky Fried Chicken.[2]

This was the beginning of what would be one of the most notorious killers in American history. He served 18 months in prison during which time his wife divorced him. After serving his time, John remarried, became heavily involved with the Jaycees, had three children, and was viewed as a fine upstanding member of society. What no one knew was that he was homosexual, and preferred violent homosexual sexual relations to heterosexual relations.[2]

Gacy went on to murder 33 boys from 1975 to 1978, hiding them in the crawlspace of his house. He hired young boys to spread lime around his basement to deal with the odor of decay. Even though there were bodies under the house, this did not stop John from having barbeques with the mayor attending among other prominent people in town. If anyone questioned the smell, it was explained away as a sewage problem.[2]

Death[]

Gacy spent his final days in an Illinois prison and was put to death by lethal injection on May 10, 1994, at the age of 52. His final meal consisted of fried chicken, french fries, fresh strawberries, and a soft drink. According to WTVR, his last words were "kiss my ass,"[3] but this was not corroborated by witnesses.[4]

His remains were cremated, and the ashes were given to the family. The Chicago-based psychiatrist Dr. Helen Morrison is currently in possession of Gacy's preserved brain. Dr. Morrison spent about 50 hours with Gacy at Cermak Hospital before his trial and was given the brain to see if there was perhaps a physical reason that could help explain what drove Gacy to murder 33 boys and young men, according to the Chicago Tribune.[5]

Victims[]

Confirmed victims[]

# Name Age Date of Death Cause of Death Recovery number Recovery location
1 Timothy McCoy 16 January 3, 1972 Stabbing Body 9 Crawlspace
2 John Doe #28 14-18 1974 Strangulation Body 28 Backyard, under BBQ pit
3 John Butkovich 18 July 31, 1975 Body 2 Garage
4 Darrell Samson 18 April 6, 1976 Body 29 Dining room
5 Randall Reffett 15 May 14, 1976 Body 7 Crawlspace
6 Sam Stapleton 14 May 14, 1976 Body 6 Crawlspace
7 Michael Bonnin 17 June 3, 1976 Strangulation Body 18 Crawlspace
8 William Carroll 16 June 13, 1976 Body 22 Crawlspace
9 John Doe #26 23-30 June–August 1976 Body 26 Crawlspace
10 James Haakenson 16 August 5, 1976 Body 24 Crawlspace
11 Rick Johnston 17 August 6, 1976 Body 23 Crawlspace
12 John Doe #13 17-22 Summer or fall 1976 Body 13 Crawlspace
13 John Doe #21 15-24 Summer or fall 1976 Body 21 Crawlspace
14 Kenneth Parker 16 October 25, 1976 Strangulation Body 15 Crawlspace
15 Michael Marino[note 3] 14 October 25, 1976 Strangulation Body 14 Crawlspace
16 William Bundy 19 October 26, 1976 Body 19 Crawlspace
17 Wayne Alexander 21 c. December 1976 Body 5 Crawlspace
18 Gregory Godzik 17 December 12, 1976 Body 4 Crawlspace
19 John Szyc 19 January 20, 1977 Body 3 Crawlspace
20 Jon Prestidge 20 March 15, 1977 Body 1 Crawlspace
21 John Doe #10 17-21 Spring or summer 1977 Body 10 Crawlspace
22 Matthew Bowman 19 July 5, 1977 Body 8 Crawlspace
23 Robert Gilroy 18 September 15, 1977 Body 25 Crawlspace
24 John Mowery 19 September 25, 1977 Body 20 Crawlspace
25 Russell Nelson 21 October 17, 1977 Body 16 Crawlspace
26 Robert Winch 16 November 10, 1977 Body 11 Crawlspace
27 Tommy Boling 20 November 18, 1977 Body 12 Crawlspace
28 David Talsma 19 December 9, 1977 Body 17 Crawlspace
29 William Kindred 19 February 16, 1978 Body 27 Crawlspace
30 Timothy O'Rourke 20 June 1978 Body 31 Des Plaines River
31 Frank Landingin 19 November 4, 1978 Body 32 Des Plaines River
32 James Mazzara 20 November 24, 1978 Body 33 Des Plaines River
33 Robert Piest 15 December 11, 1978 Body 30 Des Plaines River

Survivors[]

Name Age Date of Attack
Donald Voorhees, Jr. 15 August 1967
Tony[6] 15 1970
Anthony Antonucci 15 July 1975
David Cram 18 August 22, 1976
Robert Donnelly 19 December 30, 1977
Jeffrey Rignall 26 March 21, 1978
Jack Merrill[7] 19 1978
Steve Nemmers[8]

Suspected victims[]

Name Age Disappeared Body Found Cause of Death
Rickey Enochs 18 June 30, 1977
Charles Hattula 25 May 13, 1978 May 23, 1978 Drowning

Retired Chicago police officer Bill Dorsch also stated he had reason to believe there might be more victims buried in the grounds of the apartment building located at the 6100 block of West Miami Avenue in Chicago — a property where Gacy is known to have been the caretaker for several years before his 1978 arrest.[9]

Timeline[]

Timeline Incomplete
This article has an Incomplete Timeline. You can help Serial Killer Database Wiki by expanding it. (August 24, 2024)
Date Age Event
March 17, 1942 0 John Wayne Gacy is born.
March 4, 1968 25 Gacy is convicted of sexually assaulting two teenage boys in Waterloo, Iowa, and is sentenced to 10 years at the Anamosa State Penitentiary.
June 18, 1970 28 Gacy is granted parole after serving 18 months of his 10-year sentence. He returns to Chicago.
February 12, 1971 Gacy is charged with sexually assaulting a teenage boy. The charges are dropped however when the boy fails to show up to the trial.
June 22, 1971 29 Gacy is arrested and charged with aggravated sexual battery of a youth. The youth attempts to blackmail Gacy, and the charges are dropped. The Iowa Board of Parole is not informed of these events.
October 18, 1971 Gacy's parole ends.
January 2, 1972 Gacy leaves a family party and upon seeing Timothy McCoy, who was waiting for a bus to Omaha, Nebraska, invited him on a sight-seeing tour of Chicago. McCoy agrees, and eventually the two arrive at Gacy's house, where McCoy could stay the night, after which Gacy would return him to the bus stop the next day.
January 3, 1972 Gacy wakes up to find McCoy silhouetted in his bedroom doorway holding a knife. Upon seeing this, Gacy panics and assumes the worst. The two engage in a struggle, which Gacy wins. Upon pinning McCoy to the ground, he stabs him repeatedly in self-defense. Upon entering the kitchen to put back the knife, he finds that McCoy had simply given Gacy the wrong impression, as McCoy had actually made breakfast for two. Gacy regarded this killing as euphoric, and pointed to it as what began the ensuing chain of events.
1973 30/31 Gacy and one of his teenage employees travel to Florida, where Gacy rapes his employee. Upon returning to Chicago, the employee finds Gacy and beats him in his front yard. Gacy dismisses his wife's concerns by alleging that the employee was angry that he had not been paid, as he had done poor painting.
January, 1974 31 Gacy commits his second murder. John Doe #28 becomes his second victim.
May, 1975 33 Gacy, who had hired Anthony Antonucci, knew that Antonucci had injured his foot. Knowing this, he went to Antonucci's house, where they drank wine and watched a movie, during which, Gacy wrestled Antonucci to the ground and cuffed him, accidentally failing to close them all the way. While out of the room, Antonucci freed himself, and when Gacy returned, Antonucci, a high-school wrestler, beat Gacy in a second scuffle, got the key and cuffed Gacy. Gacy then convinced Antonucci that he would leave if Antonucci would release him, which Antonucci allowed. Gacy would not attack him again.
July 31, 1975 John Butkovich, 18, disappears after an argument with Gacy over unpaid wages.
March 2, 1976 Carole Hoff divorces Gacy. His attacks increase in frequency due to his living alone. He dubs the remainder of his kills as part of his "Cruising Years."
April 6, 1976 34 Darrell Samson, 18, disappears in Chicago.
May 14, 1976 Randall Reffett, 15, returns home from the dentist's office and disappears, his friend, Samuel Stapleton, 14, disappears on his way home. They become Gacy's fifth and sixth victims respectively.
June 3, 1976 Michael Bonnin, 17, disappears on his way to Wakugen, Illinois after stopping in Chicago, Illinois.
June 13, 1976 Gacy murders William Carroll, a 16-year old, and Gacy's eighth victim.
August 5, 1976 Following a phone call to his family, possibly from Gacy's home, James Haakenson, 16, disappears.
August 6, 1976 Gacy murders Rick Johnston, 17, who becomes Gacy's tenth victim.
August 21, 1976 18-year old David Cram, one of Gacy's employees, moves into Gacy's home with him.
August 22, 1976 To celebrate Cram's 19th birthday, the two have drinks together with Gacy dressed as Pogo the Clown. He tricks Cram into putting on handcuffs, locked in front rather than behind. Gacy grabs the cuff chain and whips Cram around, informing him that he is going to rape him, however, Cram kicks Gacy in the face and frees himself.
August/October, 1976 Sometime during this period, Gacy murders John Doe #13 and John Doe #21.
October, 1976 Gacy makes another attempt to rape Cram, Cram successfully resists Gacy's advances, and forces him to back off.
October 5, 1976 David Cram moves out of Gacy's house, Michael Rossi quickly takes his place.
October 24, 1976 Kenneth Parker and his friend, Michael Marino, both 14, are killed by Gacy, becoming his 13th and 14th victims respectively.
October 26, 1976 William Bundy, 19, an alleged employee of Gacy's, informs his parents he will be attending a party, he goes missing whilst out.
November/December, 1976 After calling his family, Francis Alexander goes missing. He is not reported missing, as he is believed to have moved to California.
December 1976 After finalizing what he believed to be "drainage ditches" in Gacy's crawl space, 17-year old Gregory Godzik is killed, and becomes Gacy's 17th victim.
January 20, 1977 Gacy offers to buy 19-year old John Szyc's Plymouth Satellite and invites him over, where he kills him, turning a profit on Szyc's car by selling it to Michael Rossi.
March 15, 1977 Jon Prestidge, 20, a recent hire of Gacy's disappears.
Spring/Summer 1977 35 Gacy kills his 20th victim, Jon Doe #10.
April, 1977 Michael Rossi moves out of Gacy's house.
July 5, 1977 Matthew Bowman disappears, whilst waiting at a suburban train station for the train to Harwood Heights, Illinois.
August, 1977 Michael Rossi attempts to steal gasoline, suspecting the car to have been stolen from Syzc, they track it back to Gacy, who informs them it was sold to him by Syzc. The police do not pursue this matter further.
September 12, 1977 Gacy leaves Chicago, and goes to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania for business.
September 15, 1977 The son of a police sergeant, 18-year old Robert Gilroy, goes missing. As Gacy was not in Chicago at the time, it is believed Gilroy's abduction was made by someone else.
September 16, 1977 Gacy returns to Chicago from his trip to Pennsylvania.
September 25, 1977 19-year old U.S. Marine, John Mowery, disappears after leaving his mother's house.
October 17, 1977 Russell Nelson, a 21-year old looking for contracting work, disappears.
October/November 1977 Gacy kills his 25th victim, 16-year old Robert Winch.
November 18, 1977 Tommy Boling, 20, disappears after leaving a bar.
December 9, 1977 David Talsma, a 19-year old U.S. Marine, tells his mother he is going to a rock concert in Hammond, Indiana. He never returns home.
December 30, 1977 Gacy abducts Robert Donnelly, 19, at gunpoint and takes him back to his house. Here he tortures Donnelly by repeatedly attempting to drown him, before releasing him at his (Gacy's) business.
January 6, 1978 Robert Donnelly reports the attack to the police. Gacy avoids arrest by convincing the authorities they have a slave-sex relationship, and that he simply hadn't paid Donnelly.
February 16, 1978 William Kindred, a 19-year old acquaintance of Gacy disappears after telling his fiancée he is going drinking. He is the final victim to be buried in Gacy's crawl space.
March 21, 1978 36 Gacy abducts Jeffrey Rignall, 26, and takes him back to his house. He proceeds to rape and torture Rignall before dumping him in Lincoln Park, Chicago, battered, but alive.
June, 1978 Timothy O'Rourke, 20, goes missing while shopping for cigarettes. He is the first victim to be thrown into the Des Plaines River.
July 15, 1978 Due to Rignall's account, Gacy is charged with battery by the State Attorney, but is not arrested. No further developments come from this charge.
November 4, 1978 Gacy commits his 30th murder. Frank Landingin, a 19-year old, and he is dumped into the Des Plaines River.
November 12. 1978 Landingin's body is discovered by duck hunters near an inlet of the Des Plains River.
November 24, 1978 Following a Thanksgiving dinner with his family, James Mazzara leaves and disappears.
December 11, 1978 Robert Piest, a 15-year-old boy, informs his mother to wait whilst he talks to a contractor about a job, and does not return. Gacy murders him an hour later. His mother files a missing person report that night, and police speak to Piest's boss at Nisson Pharmacy. This leads police to investigate Gacy, making him a suspect.
December 12/13, 1978 Due to the police investigation, Gacy successfully convinces the police that his uncle had just died, and he would arrive at the station later. Gacy used the time between then to discard Piest's body into the Des Plaines River. Following this, Gacy was in a minor accident that resulted in his car sliding off the road, which needed to be pulled from the mud, which resulted in Gacy arriving at the station covered in mud.
December 13, 1978 After obtaining a warrant, police search Gacy's house, assuming that Piest is being held prisoner there. They are unable to locate Piest, but find a number of suspicious items.
December 14, 1978 Gacy's vehicles, both his personal car, and his business vans, are confiscated. Michael Rossi also calls the authorities, informing them of Gregory Godzik's disappearance, and the death of one of Gacy's employees, Charles Hattula. The latter of which has yet to be confirmed as one of Gacy's victims.
December 15, 1978 One of the suspicious items, a class ring engraved with "J.A.S." is traced back to John Szyc. His mother informs authorities that a number of things were also taken from Szyc's apartment.
December 16, 1978 David Cram reveals to the police that, due to poor timekeeping, he had been given a watch from Gacy, who mentioned at the time that he received it "from a dead person."
December 17, 1978 Michael Rossi reveals to the police that he had bought Szyc's car from Gacy, who had informed him Szyc needed money to make a new life in California. A search dog investigation of Gacy's car revealed that Piest's corpse had been transported in the back seat.
December 18, 1978 Due to police surveillance, Gacy began to become stressed, he visited with his lawyer to create a $750,000 civil suit against the Des Plaines police with a demand to end surveillance. One of the other suspicious items, a Nisson pharmacy photo receipt was traced to Kimberly Byers, who told authorities she had borrowed Piest's parka, and had accidentally left the receipt in the pocket before returning it to him.
December 19, 1978 The police obtained a second search warrant on the same day that Gacy's civil suit was filed, which was scheduled for December 22nd. One officer distracted Gacy, whilst the other attempted to check Gacy's Motorola TV's serial number, a suspicious item possibly linked to Szyc, but was unable to get it. Whilst using the bathroom however, the officer noted what smelled like rotten flesh emanating from a heating vent.
December 20, 1978 When questioned where Piest's body may be, Rossi informed the officers of the crawl space, as Rossi had previously been asked to spread ten bags of lime, as well as digging a ditch in there. Cram told officers that he had also been asked to do similar things in the crawl space. That evening, Gacy visited with his lawyers about the upcoming civil suit, while there he became intoxicated, and confessed to the murder of Piest. He continued his confession, stating he had murdered at least 30 others, and dumped five into the river
December 21, 1978 Gacy drove to numerous locations on December 21st, fearing his arrest. At one point he handed cannabis to a gas station attendant, who turned it over to the surveillance team. Over the course of the day, Gacy became increasingly erratic, and fearing a potential suicide, took him into custody for possession and distribution of cannabis. When told his house was going to be searched for Piest, he informed them that his body wasn't there, but he had at one point, killed a boy in self-defense, and buried him in the garage. During this time, the second search warrant reveals human remains in the crawl space belonging to multiple different victims, all of which are too decomposed to be Piest. John Gacy is arrested and is charged with homocide.
December 22, 1978 Gacy formally issues a confession, remarking that he had killed about 30 young men, all of which had entered his home willingly, and were either run-aways or prostitutes. He names some, but claims he could not remember most of them. He claims to have dug five graves, but had his employees later dig trenches, which would act as the graves moving forward. He later confessed that in January of the following year, he would have poured cement into the crawl space to further hide the bodies.
February 6, 1980 37 Gacy is found guilty of 33 murders and is sentenced to death.
February 15, 1983 40 John Gacy is stabbed once in the upper left arm by fellow inmate Henry Brisbon at Menard Correctional Center.[10]
May 10, 1994 52 Is executed by lethal injection.

Bibliography[]

Literature[]

  • Gacy, John Wayne (1995). A Question of Doubt: The John Wayne Gacy Story, Craig Bowley Consultants. ISBN 978-1878865038
  • Sullivan, Terry; Peter Maiken (2000). Killer Clown: The John Wayne Gacy Murders, Pinnacle. ISBN 978-0786014224
  • Amirante, Sam L.; Danny Broderick (2011). John Wayne Gacy: Defending a Monster: The True Story of the Lawyer Who Defended One of the Most Evil Serial Killers in History,. ISBN 978-1632203632
  • Conti, Karen (March 26, 2024). Killing Time with John Wayne Gacy: Defending America's Most Evil Serial Killer on Death Row, Black Lyon Publishing. ISBN 979-8986512471

Articles[]

Documentaries[]

Television[]

YouTube Documentaries[]

Podcasts[]

In popular culture[]

Film adaptations[]

Trivia[]

  • Incarcerated serial killer Brian Dugan has identified Gacy as the offender guilty of kidnapping and sodomizing Dugan when he was a teenager.
  • In 1978, actor Jack Merrill claimed he was kidnapped, assaulted, and later released by John Wayne Gacy, who gave him his phone number afterward; Merrill didn't report it, unaware Gacy was a killer.[14][7]
  • Disgraced Nickelodeon dialogue/acting coach & producer Brian Peck had a pen pal relationship with John Wayne Gacy.[15][16]

Related Articles[]

See also[]

Links[]

Notes[]

  1. Sometimes called Carole Lofgren.
  2. Execution Chamber With Viewing Window At A Prison. Gettyimages.
  3. Identification disputed.
  4. 8213 refers to Gacy's home address, which was 8213 West Summerdale, Norwood Park Township, Illinois, United States
  5. Working title. Initial reports say it will be John Wayne Gacy: Devil in Disguise[13]

References[]

  1. John Wayne Gacy Reveals the Infamous Rope Trick on YouTube
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 John Wayne Gacy. Clark County Prosecutor.
  3. Alix Bryan (January 17, 2013). "HOLMBERG: Killer’s final words – "Kiss my ass" – not original among executed.". WTVR. Archived from the original on January 24, 2022.
  4. Gacys last words confirmed by witnesses on YouTube
  5. Jane Fritsch (May 29, 2004). "Psychiatrist has Gacy's brain in her basement". Chicago Tribune. Archived from the original on October 4, 2018.
  6. John Gacy Survivor interview-Tony, Soft White Underbelly on YouTube
  7. 7.0 7.1 Lauren McIver (October 25 2024). Hollywood Actor Reveals He Was Kidnapped and Raped by Serial Killer John Wayne Gacy Aged 19. Radar Online.
  8. Viswa Vanapalli (April 19, 2022). "Where is Steve Nemmers Now?". TheCinemaholic.
  9. Steve Mills (March 30, 2012). "Sheriff barred from digging for more Gacy victims". Chicago Tribune. Archived from the original on November 7, 2012.
  10. "Gacy stabbed by another death row inmate". United Press International Archives (February 15, 1983).
  11. John Wayne Gacy: Devil in Disguise trailer, Peacock Youtube
  12. Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes trailer, Netflix
  13. John Squires (June 20, 2024). Michael Chernus Playing John Wayne Gacy in Peacock’s ‘Devil in Disguise’. Bloody Disgusting.
  14. I Survived the John Wayne Gacy Murders, People on YouTube
  15. Mollie Quirk (March 18, 2024). Disgraced Nickelodeon coach Brian Peck was pen pals with serial killer and boasted to little kids. The Mirror.
  16. Former Nickelodeon child star alleges connection between producer and Chicago serial killer John Wayne Gacy. NBC Chicago (March 18, 2024).